The Gazette 1989

GAZETT ^ INCORPORATE D L LA W SOCIET Y J O F IRELAND • • •1 Vol . 83 No. 1 Januar y 1989

1

Peter Sutherland, S.C., former Irish Commissi

oner to the EEC.

1

kit

\

L

éaált! •

\

1 wt^É m

1

B k \

\

European Issue

GAZETTE

INDEX 1989

SUBJECT INDEX This is a comprehensive index to subjects covered in the Gazette, with entries also under major headings such as, Acts of the Oireachtas, Articles, Associations and Societies; Book Reviews, Editorials, European Communities; Law Society; Practice Notes, President's Column, Solicitors etc. Pictorial items are indexed under People and Places. Local and international societies are indexed under Associations and Societies, Sports activities, or People and Places (if pictorial references only). Note: References are to issue number followed by page number. Abbreviations: (edl.) - Editorial/viewpoint; HC - High Court; LRC - Law Reform Commission; (Itr.) - letter to the Editor; (pr:) - Practice note; (Pres.) - President's column; SC - Supreme Court. ACCIDENTS Whiplash injury (C. J. Muldoon), 12 431-2 work, at, see Occupational health and safety see also : Fatal accidents: Personal injuries; Road traffic accidents. ACTS OF THE OIREACHTAS Criminal Law (Jurisdiction) Act 1976, 4 117; 5 164. Data Protection Act 1988, (D. C. Linehan), 3 89-90. Extradition Act 1965, 4 117; 6 161. Extradition (Amendment) Act 1987, 4 118. Finance Act 1989, 8 288 Judicial Separation and Family Law Reform Act 1989, (edl.), 9 299 Jurisdiction of Courts and Enforcement of Judgments (European Communities) Act, 1988 (E. McAuley), 3 94-100; (S. Casey), 3 101-04 Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 1989 (D. Madden, J. Brennan), 9 301-07 Status of Children Act 1987 (C. Lehane), 11 403-08; 12 443-46 ADMINISTRATION OF ESTATES non-marital children, rights of, see Status of Children Act 1987 ADVOCACY litigating in Luxembourg (Sir Gordon Slynn), 1 13-15 UK reform proposals, (edl.), 3 75 solicitors and, (edl.), 3 75 ACCOUNT SYSTEMS computerised accounting (F. J. Binchy), 2 63-4 AGREEMENTS competition provisions, see under Competition Law AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL Lawyers' group (Itr.), 6 224 ARCHITECT'S CERTIFICATE summary judgment on foot of, - Rohan Construction -v- Antigen (P. Sreenan), 6 197-8 ARREST extradition purposes, for, 4 119-20

ARTICLES Advice on Investments (C. Rapple), 2 57-9 Article 5.1 of the Brussels Convention (J. M. Bosnak), 8 273-8 Capital Acquisitions Tax and the Favourite Nephew Relief - recent developments (D. Kennedy), 9 321-5, 330 The Civil Legal Aid Scheme - Scope and operation (T. Dalton), 4 137-42 The Company Auditor - Principles of Civil Liability (M. Ford), 11 385-9 Computerised Accounting for Solicitors - Do you need it? (F. J. Binchy), 2 63-4 Dancing with the Dinosaurs - ISLBA Charity Ball (C M. O'Tuama), 7 231-2 Data Protection Act 1988 - Must you register? (D. C. Linehan), 3 89-90 Defective Building Work: Who should pay? (W. Binchy), 2 41-4; 3 77-9 Eurlegal (K. Murphy), 3 85-7 The European Economic Interest Grouping (A.M. Neary; R. Caplan), 8 266-8 Insurance Consultancy and Risk Management (P. Kilcullen), 7 245-7 Interview with Brian Walsh, Justice, Supreme Court; Judge, European Court of Human Rights (from G. Sturgess, P. Chubb, Judging the World), 10 348-53 Interview with Thomas Finlay, Chief Justice, Supreme Court (from G. Sturgess, P. Chubb - Judging the World), 7 242-3 Interview with Thomas O'Higgins, Judge, Court of Justice of the European Communities (from G. Sturgess, P. Chubb, Judging the World), 8 283-4 An Introduction to the Jurisdiction of Courts and Enforcement of Judgments (European Communities) Act, 1988 (E. McAuley), 3 94-100 Judging the World - interviews see Interviews (above) The Larceny Bill 1989 - New Offence of Handling Stolen Property (W.O'Dea), 12 421-6 The Law Relating to the Status of Children born outside Marriage and their Property Rights (C. Lehane), 11 402-08; 12 443-6 The Legal Implications of 1992 (P. D. Sutherland), 1 5-9 Life Assurance (C. Rapple), 4 129-30 Litigating in Luxembourg (reprinted from Counsel), (Sir G. Slynn) 1 13-15 Multi-disciplinary Partnerships (H. Collot d'Escury - CCBE paper), 1 24-5 New Facilities at Four Courts, 10 357 New Laws for Co-ops? (A. Quinn), 7 225-6 1992 - Completing the Internal Market (M. Hutchings), 1 27-9 No Need to Notify? - Block exemptions under Art. 85 of the Treaty of Rome (A.D.S. Moran), 8 257-63 Notes on the 1968 European Communities (Judgments) Convention, the Act of the Oireachtas which enabled Ireland to ratify it, and the District Court Rules made thereunder (S. Casey), 3 101-04 An Outline of Extradition Law (P. Charleton), 4 117-25; 5 161-5 Recognition of Higher Education Qualifications (Diplomas) - Europen Information Leaflet No. 3, 8 279-80 Reservation of Title (M. Hanley), 6 213-18 Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 1989 (D. Madden, J. Brennan), 9 301-07

3

INDEX 1989

GAZETTE

A Dictionary of Irish Law (H. Murdoch), rev. by C. R. Meredith, 1 31 Freedom, the Individual and the Law (6th ed. - G. Robertson) rev. by E. G. Hall, 8 290-1 Imprisonment: the legal status of Prisoners (G. D. Treverton-Jones), rev. by T. Cahill, 8 290 Inheritance Tax (B. McCutcheon) rev. by B. A. Bohan, 5 187-8 The Interpretation of Contracts (K. Lewison) rev. by P. Fagan, 11 409 Irish Institutional Investment Reference Journal 1989 (T. Ryan, ed) rev. by P. J. McGovern, 11 409-10 The Larceny Act 1916 (J. P. McCutcheon) rev. by M. Staines, 2 66-7 The Law and Practice of Administrative Receivership and associated remedies (Lange and Hartwig) rev. by J. Marshall, 12 451 LRC Report on Land Law and Conveyancing Law rev. by E. Brunker, 12 448-51 LRC: 10th Report (1988) rev. by E. G. Hall, 6 222 New Directions in Judicial Review (J. L. Jowell, D. Oliver) rev. by E. G. Hall, 2 66 Review of European Community Law in Ireland (B. McMahon, F. Murphy), 6 222 Valuation of Property for Rating Purposes (Valuation Office) rev. by C. R. Meredith, 12 448 BRUSSELS CONVENTION Act of the Oireachtas (E. McAuley), 3 94-100; and District Court Rules (S. Casey), 3 101-04 enforcement of Irish judgments abroad, 3 100, 102-03 jurisdiction (Art.5.1), (J. Bosnak), 8 273-8 jurisdiction provisions, 3 95-6, 101 non-recognition of foreign judgments 3 100 procedure, 3 97-100; 102-04 provisional/protective measures, 3 100 recognition and enforcement of judgments, 3 94-5, 102 scope of, 3 94-5, 101 service of documents 3 103-04 BUILDING DEFECTS Architect's Certificate - counterclaims for defective workmanship (P. Sreenan), 6 197-8 liability in tort - D & F. Estates -v- Church Commissioners (W. Binchy), 2 41-4; 3 77-9 BUILDING SOCIETIES conveyancing services (Pres.), 2 45; 3 81; 4 127 tiered rates (Itr.), 1 32 BUILDING SOCIETIES BILL (Pres.), 3 81 CAT see Capital Acquisitions Tax CCBE multi-disciplinary partnerships 1 24-5 certificates of discharge (Revenue Commrs.) 9 331 Favourite Nephew Relief - recent developments (D. Kennedy), 9 321-5, 330 gifts (J. Quinlan), 5 177-8 Inheritance Tax (B. McCutcheon) rev. 5 187-8 statutory self-assessment (J. Reid, T. Fitzpatrick), 10 373-5 4 VAT reduction resolution, 7 235 CAPITAL ACQUISITIONS TAX

Service of Documents by FAX (E. G. Hall), 9 318 Set-off and Counter-claim - Deciphering the Irish Rules (C. Doyle), 10 367-9 Solicitors' Computer Systems - What next? - Unix v. Networking (F. Lanigan), 10 361-5 Sources of European Community Law (M. Byrne), 1 20-23; 2 49-53 Statutory Deductions from Damages in Tort (D. Maloney), 10 341-6 Statutory Self-Assessment for Capital Acquisitions Tax (J. Reid and T. Fitzpatrick), 10 373-5 Summary Judgment on foot of an Architect's Certificate - a conflict resolved? (P. Sreenan), 6 197-8 Taxing the Voluntary Disposition inter vivos (J. F. Quinlan), 5 177-81 Unit Linked funds (C. Rapple), 6 205-06 Whiplash (C. J. Muldoon), 12 431-2 Why you should join Solicitors Financial and Property Services (P. Prost), 8 271-2 X-Rays and the Law (S. Hamilton), 7 239-41 ASSOCIATIONS AND SOCIETIES {note: for sports associations, see under Sports activities; for pictorial items, see under People and Places] Association of Criminal Lawyers 4 142 Concerned Lawyers Association for Social Problems 7 229 Irish Solicitors in London Bar Assoc. AGM 12 435; Charity Ball (C. M. O'Tuama), 7 231-2; (Pres.), 6 199 Medico-Legal Society - Council 1989-90, 8 371 Solicitors' Benevolent Association, 6 209, 11 408 Sports associations and clubs see Sports activities Society of Young Solicitors AGM, 8 287; Officers and committee 1989-90, 8 287; Spring seminar, 5 171; Autumn seminar, 11 393 YMC see Younger Members Committee AUDITOR OF COMPANY duty of care - liability in tort (M. Ford), 11 385-9 AVOIDANCE SEE TAX AVOIDANCE BANKS mortgages, release of, (pr.), 5-169 undertakings to, see Undertakings BAR litigating in Luxembourg (Sir Gordon Slynn), 1 13-15 UK reform proposals (edl.), 3 75 BLIND PERSONS braille law book launch, 8 289 BOOK LAUNCHES braille edition of A Dictionary of Irish Law (H. Murdoch), 8 289 BOOK REVIEWS Annual Review of Irish Law (R. Byrne, W. Binchy) rev. by E. G. Hall, 12 447-8 Cases and Comment on Irish Commercial Law and Legal Technique (R. Byrne), rev. by D. Tomkin, 3 107 Debt Collection: I) The Law relating to Sheriffs (LRC), rev. by M. Hayes, 3 107-08

INDEX 1989

GAZETTE

CONTRACTS The Interpretation of Contracts (K. Lewison) rev. by P. Fagan, 11 409 sale of goods, see Sale of Goods

CAPITAL GAINS TAX gifts (J. Quinlan), 5 178 retirement relief 9 325-6

CHILD ABDUCTION Hague Convention (edl.), 1 3,5

CONTRIBUTORS [see under Articles]

CHILDREN non-marital - status and property rights (C. Lehane), 11 402-08; 12 443-6 see also Child abduction

CONVENTIONS child abduction see Hague Convention EEC Judgments Convention see Brussels Convention CONVEYANCING building societies, by, (Pres.), 2 45; 3 81; 4 127 law reform (Pres.), 8265; 10347 LRC: Report on lAnd lAw and Conveyancing (Pres.) 10347; reviewed, 12 448-51 CONVEYANCING COMMITTEE practice notes 2 47; 5 159; 6202; 7229; 8269; 9 313-14 see further under Practice Notes CORRESPONDENCE Amnesty International - Lawyers' group (N. Blackwell), 6 224 building societies - tiered rates (K. O'Higgins), 1 32 CAT - certificates of discharge (J. Reid, Revenue Commrs.) 9 331 Company Index Service (P. Farrell, Companies Office), 9 331 Dept. of Justice and the Law Society (R. Burke, Minister), 9 331 Law Clerks' ERO - arrears (K. Bonner, Dept. of labour), 9 411 Lawyers' Fishing Club of Ireland (A. O'Gorman), 5 185 master leases (J. Curran), 11 411 shopping centre leases (G. Eaton), 3 108 stamp duty on non-grant new houses (R. O'Donnell), 11 411 structured settlements (M. Kemp, IIF), 12 452 tax avoidance - Finance Act 1989 (A. Reynolds, Minister), 8 288 CO-OPERATIVES new laws for ? (A. Quinn), 7 225-6

CIVIL LEGAL AID SCHEME Scope and operation (T. Dalton), 4 137-42

CIVIL LIABILITY company auditor (M. Ford), 11 385-9 statutory deductions from damages (A. Moran), 8 257-63

CLAWBACK leased milk quota~ (pr.), 6 202

CLUBS see under Sports activities

COMMERCIAL LAW Cases and Comment on Irish Commercial Law and Legal Technique (R. Byrne), rev. 3 107

COMPANIES OFFICE Company Index Service (ltr.), 9 331 registration of charges (pr.), 1 17

COMPANY LAW company Auditor - principles of civil liability (M. Ford), 11 385-9 company names -checking system (pr.), 2 47 EC directives and regulations - progress report, 4 145 European Economic Interest Grouping (A. Neary, R. Caplan), 8 266-8 insolvencies see: Insolvencies; Reservation of Title registration of charges (pr.), 1 17 Takeover Bids Directive, 3 87 COMPENSATION FUND (Pres.), 7 227 fraudulent undertakings, liability on basis of, 9 327-8

COMPENSATION PAYMENTS see Structured settlements

COUNTER-CLAIMS see Set-off and Counter-claim

COMPETITION, PROFESSIONAL (Pres:), 5 166-7

COURTHOUSES Four Courts - new facilities at, 10 357 Law Society survey, (edl.), 4 115

COMPETITION, LAW (Treaty of Rome) block exemptions under Art. 85, 1 6; 3 85; (A. Moran), 8 257-63

CREDIT UNIONS law reform, call for, 7 226

COMPUTERISED ACCOUNTING solicitors, for, (F. J. Binchy), 2 63-4

CRIMINAL INJURIES COMPENSATION statutory deductions 10 345

COMPUTERS solicitors' offices, see Office management

CRIMINAL LAW confessions by suspects (pr.), 11 383 extradition see Extradition Law Guildford Four - Dail to examine Irish procedures, 12439 handling stolen property (W. O'Dea), 12 421-6 interrogation of suspects (edl.), 11 383

CONFESSIONS BY SUSPECTS (edl.), 11 383 Dail committee to examine procedures, 12 439

CONSTITUTION OF IRELAND Supreme Court developments - interview with Brian Walsh, Justice, 10 348-53 5

INDEX 1989

GAZETTE

EMPLOYMENT, SAFETY IN, see Occupational health and safety ENFORCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS see Brussels Convent ion EURLEGAL CAMPAIGN launch of, 8 255 law brief (K. Murphy), 3 85-7

The Larceny Act /9/6 (J. P. McCutcheon) rev. by M: Staines, 2 66-7 Larceny Bill 1989 (edl.) 12 419 (W. O'Dea), 12 421-6 reveiw of criminal law, call for, (edl.), 12 419

CUSTODY OF CHILDREN see Child abduction

DAIL EIREANN Lawbrief (E. G. Hall), 12 439-41 legislative efficiency (edl.), 7 223

EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES

CCBE - VAT reduction resolution, 7 235 European Economic Interest Grouping, 8 266-8 internal market, see Single European Market Judgments and Jurisdiction Convention, see Brussels Convention law see: European Community Law legal profession, future of, I 7, 9; (edl.), 8 255, 257 Official Journal 1 21 publications of, (M. Byrne) I 21, 23; 2 49-50 recognition of higher qualifications see under Reciprocity of qualifications EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES (JUDGMENTS) CONVENTION 1968 see Brussels Convention EUROPEAN COMMUNITY LAW company law directives and regulations, 8 258 competition, see Competition Law JUSTIS on-line database (Pres.), 5 167; 8 255 legal implications of 1992 (P. Sutherland), 1 5-9 new laws law brief (K. Murphy), 3 85-7 and see Eurlegal Review of European Community Law in Ireland (B. McMahon, F. Murphy), 6 222 sources of, (M. Byrne) I 20-23; 2 49-53 see also: European Court of Justice; Irish Centre for European Law

DAMAGES statutory deductions from, (D. Maloney), 10 341-6

DATA PROTECTION ACT 1988 Must you register? (D.C. Linehan), 3 89-90

DEDUCTIONS damages in tort (D. Maloney), 10 341-6

DEFECTIVE BUILDING WORK see Building defects

DEFECTIVE PRODUCTS see Product liability

DISPOSITIONS see Gifts

DISTRIBUTION AGREEMENTS exe~ptions under Art.85, Treaty of Rome, 8 258 DOCUMENTS service of, by Fax see Fax transmissions stamping see Stamping of documents DRINKS INDUSTRY exemptions under Art.85, Treaty of Rome 8 258

DUBLIN DISTRICT COURT civil proceedings (pr.), 1 17; 6 201

EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS interview with Judge Brian Walsh, 10 348-53

EDITORIALS (VIEWPOINT) advocacy services, UK reform proposals, 3 75 child abduction, I 3

EUROPEAN COURT OF JUSTICE interview with Judge Thomas O'Higgins, 8 283-4 litigation procedure (Sir Gordon Slynn), 1 13-15 EUROPEAN ECONOMIC INTEREST GROUPING main features of, (A. M. Neary, R. Caplan), 8 266-8

confessions by suspects, II 383 courthouse accommodation, 4 115 European integration see Single European Market (below) Eurphoria, I 11

interrogation of suspects, 11 383 Judicial Separation Act 1989, 9 299 Land Registry staffing, 2 39 Larceny Bill 1989, 12 419 legislative process, efficiency of, 7 223

EUROPEAN INTEGRATION see Single European Market

EVIDENCE

X-Rays as, 7 239

personal injuries - structured settlements, 10 339 receiving stolen property - Larceny Bill 1989, 12 419 Single European Market (1992), readiness for, I 3; 8 255 Solicitors' Financial and Property Services,S 159 stamping of documents, withdrawal of postal facilities, 2 39

EXTRADITION LAW (P. Charleton), 4 117-25; 5 161-5 arrest 4 119-20 Attorney General, role of 4 liS burden of proof 4 123 Constitutional protection 5 163 corresponden~e 4 121, 123

structured settlements, 10 339 suspects, confessions by, II 383 suspects, interrogation of, II 383 Wills Registry, 6 195

countries other than UK,S 161-4 delay and discrimination 5 163-4 identity of prisoner 4 t 23

6

INDEX 1989

GAZETTE

ILLEGITIMATE CHILDREN see Non-Marital Children INHERITANCE TAX see Capital Acquisitions Tax INSOLVENCIES The Law and Practice of Administrative Receivership and associated remedies (Lange and Hartwig) rev. by J. Marshall, 12 451 see also Reservation of title INSURANCE life assurance (C. Rapple), 4 129-30 see also Solicitors' Financial and Property Services

politial offence exemption 4 118; 5 162-3 United Kingdom, to, 4 117-25 validity of warrants etc. 4 120-2 FAMILY HOME PROTECTION ACT judgment mortgages and, (Dail Debate, Nov. 1989), 12 441 FAMILY LAW child abduction (edl.), 1 3, 5 Judicial Separation Act 1989, (edl.), 9 299 non-marital children - status and property rights (C. Lehane), 11 402-08; 12 443-6 FATAL ACCIDENTS statutory deductions from damages 10 344 FAX TRANSMISSIONS (Pres.), 4 127; (pr.), 6 201; 12 433 service of documents by, - Ralux NV/SA -v- Spencer Mason (E. G. Hall), 9 318 FEES RT.A. fee scale (pr.), 6 201 FINANCIAL INVESTMENTS see Investments FINANCIAL SERVICES See Solicitors' Financial and Property Services see also Insurance consultancy FOREIGN JUDGMENTS, ENFORCEMENT OF, see Brussels Convention FOUR COURTS new facilities at, 10 357 FRANCHISE AGREEMENTS block exemptions under Art.85, Treaty of Rome, 3 85; 8 260-1 FRAUDULENT UNDERTAKINGS Compensation Fund and, 9 327-8 GARDA SIOCHANA compensation cases - statutory deductions 10 344-5 interrogation of suspects (edl.), 11 383 GIFTS, TAXATION OF, (J. Quinlan), 5 177-81

INSURANCE CONSULTANCY Risk Management, and, (P. Kilcullen), 7 245-7

INTERNAL MARKET see Single European Market

INTERROGATION OF SUSPECTS (edl.), 11 383

INTERVIEWS (JUDGES) Brian Walsh, Justice, Supreme Court; Judge, ECHR 10 348-53 Thomas Finlay, Chief Justice, Supreme Court 7 242-3 Thomas O'Higgins, Judge, Court of Justice of the European Communities 8 283-4 (from G. Sturgess, P. Chubb, Judging the World) INVESTMENTS, ADVICE ON, (C. Rapple) 2 57-9 life assurance, 4 129-30 unit linked funds 2 57, 59; 6 205 see also Solicitors Financial and Property Services IRISH CENTRE FOR EUROPEAN LAW address of Peter Sutherland, - "Legal implications of 1992", 1 5-9 publications of, 2 53 JUDGES interviews with, (from Judging the World) see Interviews (above) JUDGMENTS, ENFORCEMENT OF, European Convention, see Brussels Convention JUDICIAL REVIEW New Directions in Judicial Review (J. L. Jowell, D. Oliver) rev., 2 66 JUDICIAL SEPARATION AND FAMILY LAW REFORM ACT 1989 (edl.), 9 299 JURISDICTION OF COURTS, CONVENTION ON, see Brussels Convention JUSTICE, DEPARTMENT OF, Law Society and, (Itr. - Minister for Justice), 9 331 JUSTIS DATABASE, (Pres.), 5 167; (edl.), 8 255 7 JUDGMENT MORTGAGE family home and, 12 441

see also Capital Acquisitions Tax GUILDFORD FOUR (edl.), 11 383 Dail to examine Irish procedures, 12 439

HAGUE CONVENTION ON CHILD ABDUCTION (edl.) , 1 3, 5 HANDLING STOLEN PROPERTY see Larceny Bill 1989 HEALTH AND SAFETY see Occupational health and safety HOUSE PURCHASE •'nancial advice (edl.), 5 159 see also Conveyancing

INDEX 1989

GAZETTE

Solicitors' Benevolent Association, 6 209; 11 408 staff news: appointments and changes Vice-President - Ernest J. Margetson correction to December 1988 issue, I II Vice-Presidents 1989-90: Donal G. Binchy, Patrick Glynn, 11 392 (pictorial) YMC see Younger Members' Committee

KNOW-HOW LICENSES block exemptions under Art.85, Treaty of Rome; J 85; 8 261, 263 LAND LAW LRC Report on Land Law and Conveyancing Law, reviewed, 12 448-51 land purchase annuities liability of vendor to discharge (pr.), 7 229 see also Conveyancing LAND REGISTRY Dail motion, 14/15 Nov. 1989, 12 439-40 staffing problems (edl.), 2 39; (Pres.), 5 166; 10 347; 12427

LAW TECH 89, 11 394

LEGAL AID civil scheme see Civil Legal Aid Scheme

LEGAL EDUCATION Entrance Examination (Pres.), 9 308, 311 Joint Legal Education Committee - meeting at Edinburgh, May 1989, (R. Woulfe), 6219, 221 Law School expansion (Pres.), 9 311 merger of law schools proposed (Pres.), 5 167 recognition and reciprocity see Reciprocity of qualifications University law degrees (Pres.), 6 199; 9 308 LEGAL INFORMATION sources for European Community Law (M. Byrne), 1 20-23; 2 49-53 see also JUSTIS (database) LEGAL PROFESSION recognition of qualifications see Reciprocity of qualifications Single European Market, in, (P. Sutherland), 1 7, 9: (edl.), 8 255, 257 single profession called for, (Pres.), 5 172 UK reform proposals (edl.), J 75; (Pres.) 12 427 see also: Bar; Solicitors LEGAL PUBLISHING Roundhall Press: Irish Statutes Annotated series, 2 67 sources of European Community Law (M. Byrne), I 20-23; 2 49-53 see also: Book launches; Book reviews

LARCENY BILL 1989 (edl.), 12 419 handlin~ stolen property (W. O'Dea), 12 421-6

LAW BRIEF Dail Debates, 12 439-41

LAW CLERKS' ERO arrears (/Ir. - Dept. of Labour), 9 411

LAW REFORM larceny see Larceny Bill 1989

LAW REFORM COMMISSION, (Pres.) 8 265 Land Law and Conveyancing (Report), reviewed, 12 448-51; (Pres.), 10 347 Receiving Stolen Property, report 1987, 12 419 10th Report, 1988, reviewed, 6 222 LAW SOCIETY [see also: Editorials; President's Column for pictorial items, see People and Places) annual conference President's address 5 166-7, 172 bye-laws (1989) (pr.), 6 201, 209 Committees 1989-90, 12 434 and see: Conveyancing Committee; Litigation Committee; Professional Purposes Committee; Taxation Committee; Technology Committee; Younger Members Committee Compensation Fund see Compensation Fund Council Dinner 1989, 5 183 (pictorial) courthouses survey (edl.), 4 115 Dept. of Justice and, (/tr.), 9 331 EC and International Affairs Committee, J 85 half-yearly general meeting, 6 209 JUSTIS database (Pres.), 5 167 law school, entry to, (Pres.), 9 311 MacGabhann -v- Law Society (HC 10 Feb. 1989), 4 146-151 President, 1989-90: Ernest J. Margetson, 11 391 President's column, see President's Column recruitment and training (Pres.), 6 199; 9 308 referral service, (Pres.) 1 II Retirement Fund, 6 209 social welfare appeals system - submission to Minister, 6203 law school expansion (Pres.) 9 311 Practice Notes, see Practice Notes Entrance examination (Pres.), 9 308, 311 EURLEGAL campaign (K. Murphy), J 85 Four Courts, new facilities at, 10 357

LEGAL SERVICES VAT on, CCBE resolution, 7 235

LEGISLATION efficiency of legislative process, (edl.), 7 223 see also Acts of the Oireachtas

LIABILITY see Civil liability; Negligence; Product liability

LIFE ASSU~ANCE (C. Rapple), 4 129-30

LITIGATION European Court, in, (Sir Gordon Slynn), I 13-15

LITIGATION COMMITTEE practice notes, 4 131, 132; 6 201 see further under Practice Notes LOST WILLS Brady, Elizabeth (Barna, Galway), J 110; 4 153 Brereton, John (Nenagh, Tippeary), 7 249

8

INDEX 1989

GAZETIE

MEDICAL NEGLIGENCE no-fault compensation (Pres.), 5 166 opthalmology panel, (pr.), 4 131 orthopaedics, (pr.), 4 132

Butler, Christopher (Tramore, Waterford), 8 293 Conneely, Edward (Prospect Hill, Galway), 6 225 Cotter, Jas, J. (Bantry, Cork), 3 110 Cuffe, Mary (DunLaoghaire), I 33 Cullen, Charles (Dublin 7), 4 153 Donnelly, Margaret Mary (Cabra, Dublin), II 413 Doody, Martin (Wexford), 3 110 Fitzgerald, Alice (Clontarf, Dublin), 6 225 Flaherty, Peter (Milltown, Galway), I 33 Fleming, Patrick (Killiney, Dublin), 3 110 Gaynor, Peter (Kells, Meath), 9 333 Greaney, Rev. Timothy (Columbans), II 413 Hallahan, Daniel (Stillorgan, Dublin), 6 225 Hanlon, Christopher (Kimmage Rd. Dublin), 6 225 Hartigan, Anne (Dublin 4), 9 333 Hayes, James (Glandore, Cork), 7 249 Heaslip, Thomas (Ballsbridge, Dublin), I 33 Kelly, John (Drumcondra, Dublin), 4 153 Lacy, Ellen (Castleblayney, Monaghan), 3 110 Leahy Daniel F. (Oughterard, Galway), 4 153 Linehan, Kathleen (Bantry, Cork), 9 333 Lynch, Bernard (Kingscourt, Cavan), 9 333 McAllister, Margaret (Killester, Dublin), II 413 McCabe, Elizabeth Vera (Dundalk, Louth), 7 249 McCarthy, Michael (Kinsale, Cork), 8 293 McCormack, Kathleen (Castleknock, Dublin), 9 333 McDonagh, Bridget (Kinnegad, Westmeath), 2 69 McGeer, Mary (Killorglin, Kerry), I 33 McGillicuddy, Con (Waterville and London), 5 189 McLennen, Edith Grace (Dublin 6), 4 153 McMahon, Patrick J. (Tulia, Clare), 3 110 Maher, Catherine (Artane, Dublin), 8 293 Murphy, Bridget (Kinnegad, Westmeath), 12 453 Niland, Nora (Toam, Galway), 3 110 O'Connell, Donal (Mallow, Cork), 5 189 O'Shea, Daniel (Kenmare, Kerry), 9 333 Osborne, John (Cashel, Tipperary), 8 293 O'Sullivan, Sheila (Dublin 8), 10 377 Rooney, Patrick (Dublin II), 10 377 Ryan, Thomas (Drumcondra Rd., Dublin), II 413 Sexton, Anthony (Ennis, Clare) II 413 Sexton, Michael (Fairview, Dublin), II 413 Shaikh, Constance (Devon, England), 3 110 Shanky, Thomas (Kells, Meath), 5 189 Sharkey, Robert (Elphin, Roscommon), 8 293 Shott, Harriet Elizabeth (Dalkey), 3 110 Urbach, Rafael (Rathfarnham, Dublin), 2 69 Wall, Thomas (Ferrybank, Waterford), 4 153 Walsh, Ellen (Kanturk, Cork), 2 69 Walsh, Rev. John 1. (Newrath, Waterford), 9 333 Walsh, Kathleen (Dun Laoghaire), 3 110 Walsh, Michael (Enfield, Meath), 1 33 Wynne, Matthew (Cloonloo, Sligo), 12 453 LUXEMBOURG see European Court MANUFACTURERS duties under Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act, 1989, 9 305 MARRIAGE BREAKDOWN judicial Separation Act 1989 (edl.), 9 299 MASTER LEASES (1. Curran), (ltr.), 11 411 MEDICAL EVIDENCE X-Rays and the law (S. Hamilton), 7 239-41 see also Whiplash

MILK QUOTAS Clawback on leased quotas (pr.) 6 202

MORTGAGES release of bank mortgages (pr.), 5 169

MOTOR INSURANCE

hit and run accidents (EEC Directive; MIBI agreement), I 17; corr 3 91

MOTOR VEHICLE AGREEMENTS block exemptions under Art.85, Treaty of Rome, 8 260

MULTI-DISCIPLINARY PARTNERSHIPS (edl.), 375 (H. Collot d'Escury - CCBE paper), I 24-5 (Pres.), 2 45 Professional Purposes Committee on, 4 133 NEGLIGENCE company auditor (M. Ford), II 385-9 defective building see under Building defects defective products see Product liability medical see Medical negligence see also Damages NEW TECHNOLOGY solicitors' offices, in, (Pres.), 4 127 and see Office management wills - preparation on word processors etc. (pr.), 5 169 see also Data Protection Act 1992 see Single European Market NON-MARITAL CHILDREN status and property rights (C. Lehane), II 402-08; 12 443-6 NORTHERN IRELAND solicitors: reciprocity of qualifications, 6 219 trainee numbers, 6 221 terrorist offences - Criminal Law (Jurisdiction) Act 1976, 4 117; 5 164 NEPHEW/NIECE see under Capital Acquisitions Tax NETWORK SYSTEMS 10 363-5

OBITUARIES

John J. Nash, 3 106

OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH AND SAFETY Barrington Commission Report 1983, 9 301 Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 1989 (D. Madden, 1. Brennan), 9 301-07

OCCUPATIONAL INJURIES BENEFITS deductions from damages, 10 342

OFFICE MANAGEMENT, (Pres.), 4 127 branch offices (Pres.), 4 127 computerised accounting (F. 1. Binchy), 2 63-4 FAX see Fax transmissions

9

GAZETTE

INDEX 1989

Law Tech 89, 11 394 new technology (Pres.), 4 127 solicitors' computer systems - UNIX v. networking (F. Lanigan), 10 361-5 Technology Committee practice notes, 5 169; 6 201; 12 433 PARTNERSHIPS international (Pres.), 1 11; 2 45 national (Pres.), 1 11 see also Multi-disciplinary partnerships PATENT LICENCE AGREEMENTS exemptions under Art.85, Treaty of Rome, 8 260 PEOPLE AND PLACES (pictorial items) Clare Law Society Ball, 3 92 Cahill, Thomas J. - Masters Degree award, 7 237 Cavan courthouse, 9 - (cover) Class of 1956, 4 143 Dictionary of Irish Law, launch of, 1 19 Dublin Solicitors' Bar Assoc. - annual dinner, 5 174, 175; Millennium meeting, Mansion House, 2 - (cover)-, President, Geraldine Clarke, 12 437; Summer Party presentation, 5 171; visit to Edinburgh, 4 134 Eurlegal - launch of JUSTIS database, 8 - (cover) European Court, visit to, 4 135 Guild of Agricultural Journalists seminar, 4 134-5 inaugural colours match - Law Society and King's Inns students, 1 18 Institute of Chartered Accountants - centenary celebrations - presentation by Law Society President, 3 - (cover) International Bar Assoc. biennial conference, 1988 - Buenos Aires, 2 54-5 Irish Centre for European Law seminar, 11 398 Johnston, Robert (President of CFE), 3 93 Jones, Peter (appointed State solr, for Westmeath), 3 92 Kerry Law Society annual dinner, 1 18 King's Hospital - Law society prize, 1 19 Law Council of Australia, President of, - visit to Blackhall Place, 11 400 Law Society - council dinner, 5 - (cover), 183; half- yearly meeting, 6 210-11 President 1988-89, Maurice Curran - tree planting ceremony, 12 436 President 1989-90, Ernest J. Margetson, 11 - (cover); staff appointment, 10 354; Summer Ball, 7 236-7; Vice-Presidents, 1989-90, 11 392 Law Society Ennis Table Quiz, 5 184 Lawtech exhibition, 11 398-9 Lawyers Desk Diary 1990 presentation, 11 390 Lunatic Lawyers' Cycling Club: Malin - Mizen 1989, 9 316-17; 12 436 Mayo Bar Association annual dinner, 1 18 Meath and Cavan Bar Associations - meeting with President of Society, 1 18 Midland Bar Association - retirement of DJ Seamus N. Mahon, 7 236 O'Connor, Pat - presentation of golf cup, 5 174 Power, Brenda (journalist), 3 92 Press Freedom and Libel, launch of, 1 19 residential Advocacy Course participants, 5 174-5 Robinson, Vicki and Michael Sweeney - wedding day, 12 437

Scally, Jimmy (Irish Red Cross), 3 92 Solicitors Benevolent Assoc. Christmas concert, 12 - (cover) Solicitors Financial and Property Services (Ireland) Ltd. 5 175; 6 - (cover) Southern Law Assoc. annual dinner, 4 135 Sutherland, Peter (former EC Commr.), 1 - (cover) Tipperary and Offaly Bar Assoc. annual dinner, 5 170 UCC BCL class of 1978 reunion, 12 436-7 undertakings, launch of new forms, 7 - (cover) Waterford Quiz night, 29 March 1989, 7 234 Waterford solicitors qualified over 50 years, 6 200 YMC - Network launch, 10 - (cover), 358-9 see also: Interviews; Obituaries PERSONAL INJURIES damages - statutory deductions from, (D. Maloney), 10 341 No-fault compensation: medical negligence (Pres.), 5 166 Structured settlements, (edl.), 10 339; (Itr.), 12 452 whiplash (C. Muldoon), 12 431-2

X-Ray evidence (S. Hamilton), 7 239-41 PHOTOGRAPHS see People and Places PLANNING practice notes, see under Practice Notes POLICE see Garda Siochana POLITICAL OFFENCE EXEMPTION extradition proceedings, in, 4 118; 5 162-3 POWERS OF ATTORNEY (pr.), 10 370 PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE

Brussels Convention proceedings, 3 97-100 European Court, see under European Court set-off see Set-off and counter-claim PRACTICE NOTES bank mortgages, release of, (Conveyancing Committee) 5 169 banks, undertakings to, 6 202; 10 370-1 Bye-Laws of the Law Society (1989) 6 201 certificate of compliance with planning permission (Conveyancing Committee), 8 269 Circuit appeals (RSC No. 2, 1989), 4 131-2 Civil Proceedings in the Dublin District Court 1 17; 6 201 clawback on leased milk quotas (Conveyancing Committee), 6 202 Companies Office - registration of charges (Company Law Committee), 1 17 company names - checking system (Companies Office), 2 47 Court list numbers (Litigation Committee), 4 132 Dalkon Shield intra-uterine device - claims, 12 433 deposits in sale generally (Professional Purposes Committee) 4 131 Dublin Corporation - legal searches (Conveyancing Committee), 9 314 Dublin District Court - civil proceedings 1 17; 6 201 fax transmissions (Technology and Litigation Committees), 6 201; 12 433

10

GAZETTE fees - R.T.A. fee scale 6 201 General Conditions of Sale - Land Purchase annuities (Conveyancing Committee ), 7 229 hit and run accidents (MIBI agreement), 1 17; 3 91 Land Purchase annuities - liability of vendor to discharge (Conveyancing Committee), 7 229 Land Registry - application for new folio for part of registered land (not involving change of ownership) 8 269-70 Lloyds Underwriters 4 132 medical negligence (orthopaedics) 4 132 medical negligence panel (opthalmology) (Litigation Committee), 4 131 m ' l k quotas - clawback on leased quotas (Conveyancing Committee) 6 202 mortgagee, sale by, (Conveyancing Committee), 9 313-14 mortgages - release of bank mortgages 5 169 motor insurance - hit and run accidents (EEC Directivé; MIBI agreement), 1 17; corr. 3 91 new technology - fax transmissions see fax transmissions (above) new technology - wills see wills (below) non-resident landlords - retention of tax from rent and proceeds of sales (Taxation Committee), 2 47 Objections and Requisitions on Title (1989 edition), 9 315 planning permission - certificate of compliance 8 269 exempted development (Conveyancing Committee), 2 47 powers of attorney 10 370 Probate Office directions, 5 169 roads and services in charge of local authority (Conveyancing Committee), 2 47 Rules of the Superior Courts 1989, 4 131-2 sale by mortgagee (Conveyancing Committee), 9 313-14 sale by private treaty - issue of contracts to auctioneers (Professional Purposes Committee), 4 131 setting down - country venues (RSC 1989), 4 131 undertakings by solicitors, 6 202; 10 370-1 wills - preparation on word processors, computers etc. (Technology Committee), 5 169 PRESIDENT'S COLUMN (Maurice R. Curran, nos. 1-10; Ernest J. Margetson, nos. 11, 12] Address to Annual Conference, 5 May 1989, 5 166-7, 172 branch offices 4 127 building societies - conveyancing services 2 45; 3 81; 4 127 Compensation fund, 7 227 competition and free movement 5 166-7 conveyancing law reform, 8 265; 10 347 conveyancing services - building societies, 2 45; 3 81; 4 127 Entrance Examination, 9 308 European Presidents' Conference, Vienna, 2 45 fax transmissions 4 127 international legal partnerships, 1 11; 2 45 Irish Solicitors in London Bar Association, 6 199 JUSTIS database 5 167 land law reform 10 347 Land Registry - staffing problems 5 166; 10 347; 12 427 Law Reform Commission, 8 265 land law report, 10 347 legal education - expansion of Law School, 9 311

INDEX 1989 legal education - merger of professional law schools, 5 167 legal education - University Law degrees, 6 199; 9 308 legal profession - need for one profession, 5172 marketing of services, 1 11 medical negligence - no fault compensation 5 166 multi-disciplinary partnerships 2 45 national partnerships, 1 11 new technology 4 127 office management 4 127 personal injury - no fault compensation 5 166 professional indemnity insurance, 11 391 reciprocity of qualifications, 6 199 recruitment and training, 6 199; 9 308 referral service, 1 11 self-regulation 5 167 Single European Market 1 11; 5 167 Solicitors Financial and Property Services, 11 391 Solicitors' Bill - submission on, 2 45 Supreme Court appeals - written submissions 5 166 UK - Courts and Legal Services Bill, 12 427 undertakings - agreed forms, 7 227 PRISONS Imprisonment: the legal status of Prisoners (G. D. Treverton-Jones), rev. by T. Cahill, 8 290 PRODUCT LIABILITY building defects - D.&F. Estates -v- Church Commrs (W. Binchy) 2 41-4; 3 77-9 complex and simple products 3 78 non-dangerous defects 2 41; 3 77 pure economic loss 2 41; 42-3; 3 77 PROFESSIONAL INDEMNITY INSURANCE (Pres) 11391 PROFESSIONAL NEGLIGENCE company auditor (M. Ford), 11 385-9 see also Medical negligence PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS see Reciprocity of qualifications PROPERTY RIGHTS non-marital children see Non-marital Children PROPERTY TRANSFERS, TAXATION OF, see Gifts PURCHASING AGREEMENTS exemptions under Art. 85, Treaty of Rome, 8 259 RADIOGRAPHS see X-Rays RATING AND VALUATION Valuation of Property for Rating Purposes (Valuation Office) rev. by C. R. Meredith, 12 448 RECEIVERSHIP see Insolvencies RECEIVING STOLEN PROPERTY LRC Report 1987 (edl.), 12 419 and see Larceny Bill 1989

INDEX 1989

GAZETTE

, SET-OFF AND COUNTER-CLAIM Architect's Certificate and, see Architect's Certificate Deciphering the Irish rules - Prendergast -v- Biddle (C. Doyle), 10 367-9 SHERIFFS Debt Collection: 1) The Law relating to Sheriffs (LRC), rev. by M. Hayes, 3 107-08 SHOPPING CENTRE LEASES (Itr.), 3 108 SINGLE EUROPEAN MARKET 1992, (Pres.), 1 11; 5 167 completing the Internal Market (M. Hutchings), 1 27-9 Europen campaign 2 53 hit and run accidents (MIBI agreement), 1 17; 3 91 Irish publications 2 53 Law Society Eurlegal campaign see Eurlegal Legal Implications of 1992 (P. D. Sutherland), 1 5-9 readiness for, (edl.) 1 3; 8 255 recognition of higher qualifications 1 9; (Europen leaflet) 8 279-80 SOCIAL WELFARE APPEALS SYSTEM Law Society submission, 6 203 SOCIAL WELFARE BENEFITS statutory deductions from damages (D. Maloney), 10 341-7 SOCIETIES see Associations and societies SOLICITORS advocacy services (edl.), 3 75 competition and free movement (Pres.), 5 166-7 computer systems see under Office management marketing of services, (Pres.), 1 11 office management see Office management professional indemnity insurance (Pres.), 11 391 reciprocity see Reciprocity of qualifications referral service (Pres.), 1 11 self-regulation (Pres.), 5 167 training, see Undertakings see also : Associations and societies; Law Society; Partnerships SOLICITORS' BILL (Pres.), 2 45 Dail question, 12 440-41 SOLICITORS FINANCIAL AND PROPERTY SERVICES (edl.), 5 159; (P. Prost), 8 271-2; (Pres.), 11 391 STOLEN PROPERTY see Larceny Bill 1989 SOURCES European Community Law (M. Byrne), 1 20-23; 2 49-53 SPORTS ACTIVITIES Lady Solicitors' Invitation Classic (golf), 11 395 Lawyers' Fishing Club of Ireland (Itr.), 5 185 Lunatic Lawyers' Cycling Club, 9 329; 9 316-17; 12 436 (pictorial) 12

RECIPROCITY OF QUALIFICATIONS, 6 219; (Pres.), 6 199; recognition of qualifications 1-9; (Europen) 8 279-80 RECOGNITION OF QUALIFICATIONS see Reciprocity of qualifications RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT block exemptions under Art.85, Trfcaty of Rome, 8 259-60 RESERVATION OF TITLE (M. Hanley), 6 213-18 reforms 6 216-17 RESTRICTIVE PRACTICES see Competition law RETAIL TRADE block exemptions under Treaty of Rome, see Franchise agreements REVENUE see Taxation REVENUE COMMISSIONERS stamping - withdrawal of postal facilities (edl.), 2 39 RISK MANAGEMENT insurance consultancy and, (P. Kilcullen), 7 245-7 ROAD TRAFFIC ACCIDENTS hit and run (MIBI agreement), 1 17; 3 91 statutory deductions from damages 10 341, 344 ROMALPA CLAUSES see Reservation of Title RULES OF THE SUPERIOR COURTS, (pr.), 4 131-2 Judgments Convention Act changes, 3 97 SAFETY, HEALTH AND WELFARE AT WORK ACT 1989 (D. Madden, J. Brennan), 9 301-07 SALE OF GOODS reservation of title (M. Hanley), 6 213-17 SALE OF LAND land purchase annuities - liability to discharge (pr.) 7 229 see also Conveyancing; Land law SCOTLAND reciprocity of qualifications, 6 219 training and trainees 6 221 SELF-ASSESSMENT CAT - (J. Reid, T. Fitzpatrick), 10 373-5 SERVICE OF DOCUMENTS FAX, by, (E. G. Hall), 9 318 SERVICE STATION AGREEMENTS exemptions under Art. 85, Treaty of Rome, 8 258-9 SERVICES, SUPPLY OF, reservation of title and, 6 215

INDEX 1989

GAZETTE

TRAINING recruitment and training (Pres.), 6 199; 9 308 UK surveys, 6 221 see also Legal education TRANSFERS OF PROPERTY, TAXATION OF, (J. Quinlan), 5 177-81 TREATY OF ROME block exemptions under Art.85, see Competiton law reference under Art. 117. 1 13, 14 UNDERTAKINGS TO BANKS agreed forms, (pr.), 6 202; (Pres.), 1 227 fraudulent, liability of Compensation Fund 9 327-8 pitfalls which may arise (pr.), 10 370-1 UNIT LINKED FUNDS (C. Rapple), 2 57, 59; 6 205-06 UNITED KINGDOM advocacy services, reform of, (edl.), 3 75 Courts and Legal Services Bill (Pres.), 12 427 extradition to, see under Extradition Law Guildford Four, release of, (edl.), 11 383 reciprocity of qualifications, 6 219 training and trainees, 6 221 UNIX COMPUTER SYSTEM, 10 361-5 VALUATION see Rating and valuation VOLUNTARY DISPOSITIONS INTER VIVOS see Gifts WHIPLASH (C. J. Muldoon), 12 431-2 asset register 6 195 preparation on word processors, computers etc. (pr.), 5 169 succession rights - non-marital children see Status of Children Act, 1987 Wills Registry, (edl.), 6 195 see also Lost Wills WORKPLACE SAFETY see Occupational health and safety X-RAYS X-Rays and the Law (S. Hamilton), 7 239-41 YOUNGER MEMBERS COMMITTEE committee members 1988-89, 2 48 diary of events 2 48 EC tour 3 83 Grand Quiz Night, 7 233 (pictorial) Joint Legal Education Committee meeting - Edinburgh, (R. Woulfe), 6 219, 221 Network scheme, 8 355 Portuguese Young Lawyers Association conference, 11 401 profile, 2 48 review of millennium year 1-10 sports activities see under Sports activities working from home, 9 329 WILLS

Solicitors' Apprentices Rugby Club v. the Bar, 1 26 Solicitors' Golfing Society, 6 223; 11 395 YMC Bowling Night, 7 233 (pictorial) YMC Soccer Blitz, 8 281 (pictorial) YMC tennis tournament 8 281 (pictorial) STAMP DUTY gifts, on, 5 177 non-grant new houses (Itr.), 11 411 STAMPING OF DOCUMENTS Withdrawal of postal facilities, (edl.), 2 39 STATUS OF CHILDREN ACT 1987 non-marital children, rights of, (C. Lehane), 11 402-08; 12 443-6 STRUCTURED SETTLEMENTS (edl.), 10 339; (Itr. - IIF), 12 452 SUCCESSION RIGHTS non-marital children, see Status of Children Act SUPPLY OF GOODS see Reservation of Title SUPREME COURT interviews: Chief Justice T. A. Finlay, 7 242-3; Justice Brian Walsh, 10 348-53 SUPREME COURT APPEALS written submissions (Pres.), 5 166 SUSPECTS confessions and interrogation, (edl.), 11 383 TAKEOVER BIDS DIRECTIVE, 3 87 TAX AVOIDANCE Finance Act 1989 (Itr. - Minister for Finance), 8 288 VAT on legal services - CCBE resolution, 7 235 voluntary disposition inter vivos (J. F. Quinlan), 5, 177-81 TAXATION COMMITTEE practice notes, 2 47 TECHNOLOGY see New technology TECHNOLOGY COMMITTEE practice notes, 5 169; 6 201; 12 433 TECHNOLOGY LAW see Data Protection Act TERRORIST CRIME Criminal Law (Jurisdiction) Act 1976, 4 117; 5 164 TAXATION CAT see Capital Acquisitions Tax

see also Extradition Law TRADE AGREEMENTS c omp e t i t i on law see Comp e t i t i on law

TRADE MARKS DIRECTIVE, 3 87

13

INDEX 1989

GAZETTE

Donoghue -v- Stevenson [1932] AC 562, 2 41, 43, 44; 379 Dunne -v- Clinton [1930] IR 366, 4 119 East River Streamship Corporation -v- Transamerica Delaval Inc. 106 S.Ct. 2295 (1986), 2 43; 3 78 Elwyn (Cottons) Ltd. -v- Pearle Designs Ltd. (HC 2 Feb. 1989), 3 99 Ettore -v- Philco Television Broadcasting Corp. 229 F.2d. 481, 8 291 F. (F.) -v- F. (C) [1987] ILRM I, 12 448 Feeney -v- Ging (HC 17 Dec. 1982), 10 341, 344 Flanagan -v- University College Dublin [1989] ILRM 469, 12 447 Fomento (Sterling Area) Ltd. -v- Selsdon Fountain Pen Co. [1958] I WLR 45, 11 385 Fried Krupp Huttenwarke AG and Kruppstahl AG -v– Quitmann Products and Fitzgerald [1982] ILRM 551, 6 215 Frigoscandia (Contracting) Ltd. -v- Continental Irish Meat Ltd. and Crowley [1982] ILRM 396, 6 215 G. (1.G.), In re, (HC 12 June 1989), 12 445-6 Gilbert-Ash (Northern) Ltd. -v- Modern Engineering (Bristol) Ltd. [1973] 3 All ER 195, 6 197 Glover -v- BLN (No.2) [1973] IR 432, 10 345 Golder -v- United Kingdom [19751 I EHRR 524, 8290 Goldrick and Coleman -v- Dublin Corporation (HC 10 Nov. 1986) 2 66; 12 447 Graham, J.G., In re, (HC 12 June 1989), 12 444 Haughton -v- Smith [1975] AC 476, 12 424 Hedley Byrne & Co. Ltd -v- Heller & Partners Ltd. [1964] AC 465, 2 41; 3 77, 78 Hegarty -v- O'Loughran [1987] ILRM 603, 379; 10342 Hegarty -v- Royal Liver Friendly Society [1985] IR 524, 6 197, 198 Hickey & Co. Ltd. -v- Roches Stores [1980] ILRM 107 10, 346 Industrial Diamond Supplies -v- Riva [1977] ECR 2175, (case 43/77), 3 100 Interview Ltd., In re, [1975] IR 382, 6 215 Ivenel v. Schwab [1982] ~.C.R. 1891 8 274, 277, 278 1.£'B. Fasteners -v- Marks Bloom & Co. [19811 3 All ER 289, 11 387 Johnston -v- Ireland"(l986) 9 EHRR 203, 11 403 Junior Books Ltd. -v- Veitchi Ltd. [1983] 1 AC 520, 2 41, 42; 3 77 K.K. -v- The Revenue Commissioners (App. Commrs. Jan, 1989) 9 324 Kane -v- The Governor ofMountjoy Prison (SC II May 1988), 4 120 Kelly -v- Boland [1989] ILRM 2373, 11 385, 386-7 Kennedy and Arnold -v-Ireland [1988] ILRM 472, 8291 Leech -v- Stokes [1937] IR 787, 11 385 London & General Bank, In re [1895] 2 Ch. 673, 11 385 M. (1), In re, (HC 24 July 1989), 12 446 McMahon -v- Leahy [1984] IR 525; [1985]] ILRM 422, S 163 McMahon -v- McDonald (HC 3 May 1988, SC 27 July 1988), 4 120 McSweeney -v- Bourke (HC 25 Nov. 1980) I I 386 McVeigh (DC 13 June 1988), 4 123 Madigan -v- AG [1986] ILRM 136, 3 107 Meah -v- McCreamer [1985] I All ER 367, 8 290 Morgan -v- Park Developments Ltd. [1983] ILRM 156, 3 79; 10 342 Murphy -v- Murphy [1980] IR 183, 12 450

ALPHABETICAL CASE INDEX , (i) Cases reported in the Recent Irish Cases supplements Connolly -v- Sweeney [1988] ILRM 483, ii DPP -v- Hoey [1987] IR 646, i DPP (Nagle) -v- Flynn [1987] IR 534, iii-iv Doyle -v- Hearne and Ors. [1988j ILRM 318, ii-iii Gilligan -v- DPP (HC 17 Nov. 1987), i Kennedy -v- Hughes Dairy Ltd. [1989] ILRM 117 ii McCarthy Construction Ltd. -v- Waterford Co. Council (HC 6 July 1987), iii PMPS Ltd. -v- Moore [1988] ILRM 526, i Cases examined and/or specially mentioned in articles, editorials, book reviews etc. (Note - passing references, footnote references etc. are omitted). A.E. -v- The Revenue Commissioners [1984] ILRM 301, 9 321, 322 323, 330 Agra Trading -v- Minister for Agriculture (HC 19 May 1983), 6-198, 10 368 Aluminium Industrie Vaassen av, -v- Romalpa Aluminium Ltd. [1976] I WLR 676; [1976] 2 All ER 552, 6 213-14 Anns -v- Merton L.B.C. [1978] AC 728, 241, 42, 44; 3 78, 79; 11 386 Aries Tanker Corporation -v- Total Transport Ltd. [19711 I All ER 398, 6 197 Attorney Generalfor Ontario -v- Perry [1934] AC 477, S 177 Attorney General-v- Nugent and Byrne (1964) 98 ILTR 139, 12 421 Attorney General -v- Smyth [1905] 2 IR, S 177 Attorney General -v- Oglesby [1966] IR 163, 12 424 Attorney General-v- Jacobs-Smith [1895] 2 QB, S 177 Bain -v- Fothergill (1874) LR 7 H.L. 158 12 449 Batty -v- Metropolitan Property Realisation Ltd. [1978] QB 554, 2 42, 44; 3 78, 79 Bevan -v- Webb [1901] 2 CH. 59, 11 385 Borden (UK) Ltd. -v- Scottish Timber Products Ltd. [1979J 3 WLR 672, 6 214, 215 Bowen -v- Paramount Builders (Hamilton) Ltd. [I977] 1 NZLR 394, 2 43, 44 Brady -v- Donegal Co. Council (HC 6 Nov. 1987), 3 79 British Transport Commission -v- Gourley [1956] AC 185, 10 345 Byrne -v- Houlihan [1966] IR 274, 10 344 Caparo Industries pic -v- Dickman and Ors. [1989] 2 WLR 316, 11 387-8 Colgan -v- Connolly Construction Company (Ireland) Ltd. [1988] ILRM 33, 3 79 Cooke -v- Walsh [1984] ILRM 208, 10 345 Council of Civil Service Unions -v- Minister for the Public Service [1985] AC 374, 12 447 D. & F. Estates Ltd. -v- Church Commissioners for England [1988] 2 WLR 368, 2 41-4; 3 77-9 D. R. -v- The Revenue Commissioners (CC June 1988), 9323 Danes -v- Powell Duffryn Associated Collieries [1942J AC 601, 10 344 Dawnays Ltd. -v- F. G. Minter Ltd. [1971] 2 All ER 1389, 6 197 De Bloos, In re, [1978] I C.M.L.R. 511 8 273-4, 276 Denilauler -v- SNC Couchet Freres [19801 ECR 1553, (case 125/79) 3 95 De Wolf -v- Cox [1976] ECR 1759 (case 42/76), 3 95 (ii) CASE COMMENT -

14

GAZETTE

INDEX 1989

O'B -v- S (1984) IR 316, 11 403 O'D -v- O'D (HC 18 Nov. 1983) 12 448

O'Leary -v- Cunningham (SC 28 July 1980), 12 424 O'Looney -v- Minister for the Public Service (SC 15 Dec, 1986) 10 344 O'Loughlin .;.v- Teeling [1988] ILRM 617, 10 342 O'Reilly -v- Mackman (1983) 2 AC 237, 2 66 O'Sullivan -v- CIE (1978) IR 409, 10 344 People (DPP) -v- Madden [1977] IR 336, 4 118 Prendergast -v- Biddle (SC 31 July 1957), 10 367-9 Quinn -v- Wren 5 163 R. -v- Board of Visitors Dartmouth Prison ex parte Smith [1987] QB 106, 8 290 R. -v- Harris 84 Cr. App. R. 75 (CA 1986), 12 422 R. -v- King [1938] 2 All ER 662, 12 422 R. -v- Moys 79 Cr. App. R. 72 (CA, 1984), 12 422 R. -v- Villensky (1892] 2 QB 597, 12 422 R. -v- Wiley (1850) 2 Den 37, 12 421 Ralux NV/SA -v- Spencer Mason (CA, The Times, 18 May 1989), 9-318 Rivtow Marine Ltd. -v- Washington Iron Works 40 DLR (3d) 530, 2 42, 43; J 77 Rohan Construction Ltd. -v- Antigen (HC 19 Jan, 1989), 6 197-8 Russell -v- Fanning [1988] ILRM 333, 5 163 S -v- S. [1983] IR 68, 12 445 Saurin -v- 0 hUadhaigh (HC 27 May 1976), 4 123 Shenavaiv Kreischer The Times, 16 Jan, 1987·European Ct. 8 274, 277, 278 Silver -v- United Kingdom [1980) 3 EHRR 475, 8 290 Siney -v- Dublin Corporation (1980] IR 400, J 79 Sisk (John) & Son Ltd. -v- Lawter Products B.V. (HC 15 Nov, 1976), 6 197, 198 Somers -v- Allen (James) (Ireland) Ltd. [1984] ILRM 437,6215 State (Gilliland) -v- Governor of Mountjoy Prison (1986) ILRM 381, 5 161, 162 State (Hayes) -v- Criminal Injuries Compensation Tribunal [19821 ILRM 210, 10 345 Sugar Distributors Ltd. -v- Monaghan Cash and Carry Ltd. [1982] ILRM 399, 6 214 Sunday Times -v- United Kingdom [1979] 2 EHRR 245, 8290 Sunderland -v- McGreavy [1987] IR 372, J 79 Tempany -v- Hynes [1976] IR 101, 12 449 Toal -v- Duignan (SC 27 Nov. 1987), J 79 Unit 2 Windows (In liquidation), In re, [1985] 3 All ER 647, 12 451 Van Gelderen -v- Seafield Gentex [1978] IR 167, 10368 Vone Securities -v- Cooke [1979] IR 59, 12 449 W. (N), In the estate oj, (HC 29 May 1979), 11 402 Wandsworth -v- Winder [19851 AC 461, 2 66 Ward -v- McMaster (SC 10 May 1988), J 79 Webb -v-Ireland [1988] ILRM 565; [19881 IR 353, 266; 12447

15

GAZETTE INCORPORATE D LAW SOCIETY OF IRELAND Vol.83 No. 1Januar y 198 V i e w p o i n ts EURPHORIA

JANUARY 1989

GAZETTE

In this Issue Viewpoints

3 The Legal Implications of 1992 5 Younger Members News 10 From the President 11 Litigating in Luxembourg 13 Diary 15 Practice Notes 17 People & Places 18 Sources of European Community Law: Where to find them 20 Multi Disciplinary Partnerships 24 1992 — Completing the Internal Market 27 Book Review 31 Correspondence 32 Professional Information 33 Executive Editor: Mary Gaynor Committee: Geraldine Clarke, Chairman Eamonn G. Hall, Vice-Chairman John F. Buckley Gary Byrne Timothy Dalton Charles R. M. Meredith Advertising: Liam O hOisin, Telephone: 305236 307860 Printing: Turner's Printing Co. Ltd., Longford. The views expressed in this publication, save where otherwise indicated, are the views of the contributors and not necessarily the views of the Council of Ihe Society. The appearance of an advertisement in this publication does not necessarily indicate approval by the Society for the Product or service advertised. Published at Blackhall Place, Dublin 7. Tel.: 710711. Telex: 31219. Fax: 710704. Daire Murphy John Schutte

continued economic health the profession depends, to assess the impact of the internal markét programme in the case of each individual company. The company solicitor, indeed, has an active role to play in that assessment and must fully familiar- ise himself with the huge changes which Europe is currently causing to the legal climate in which industry must compete. As Peter Sutherland points out elsewhere in this Gazette, the 1992 Program, indeed the whole European integration process, is composed of law and it behoves all lawyers to master it and bring it to the attention of their clients. If this does not occur soon, then a new word may have to be coined and addressed to both Irish industry and the legal profession - 'Eurlosingout'! • CHILD ABDUCTION A number of recent cases which involved the alleged abduction of children either from or to Ireland by estranged parents has highlighted the absence of any proper legal structure governing such cases. In 1985 the Law Reform Commission recommended that Ireland should adhere to the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction but action does not appear to be imminent. At that time the Department of Justice was also considering Ireland's adherence to a Council of Europe Convention on Recognition and Enforcement of Decisions Concerning Custody of Children and Restoration of custody of children. Ireland actually signed this convention subject to ratification in 1980. It is notorious that Ireland's record of ratification of International Conventions is deplorable though occasionally this may be justified by the fact that some of the Conventions have found little support elsewhere. Contd. on pago B

The publication last month of a comprehensive survey of '1992 Readiness' within Irish industry conducted by The Marketing Ins- titute is profoundly disturbing. It provides hard statistical evidence, firstly, that Irish industry is highly aware of 1992, secondly, is extremely optimistic about it and thirdly has no proper basis for this optimism. The survey, conducted in October 1988, shows 74% of the Chief Executives questioned viewed the likely impact of 1992 as 'favourable', 10% thought it could go 'either way' and only 14% believed it would be 'unfavourable'. The most revealing responses, however, were those which showed that 77% of companies had made no assessment whatso- ever of the impact which 1992 would have on them and indeed 40% went on to state that they did not even plan to do this in the future. More worrying still was the fact that the replies showed a wide- spread and deep misunderstanding of what 1992 was all about. The research concluded that there was a situation of "dangerous com- placency". There is a high awareness of 1992 but not of what it means. Worse, there is a belief that it means something different from what it really does. If we were to follow the Govern- ment into word play we could say that 'Europen' has led to a dangerous 'Eurphoria'. There is a strong argument to be made that 1992 will be anything but an unmixed blessing for Irish industry. Whatever the balance of benefits and threats of 1992 may be, however, there can be no questioning the need to address the issue and prepare for it. Every business in the country has solicitors who advise it. The legal profession has not played a sufficient role to date in urging its commercial clients, on whose

3