Debating Society_Minute book_1938-45

^Ct^t/

x^2t-

^o

^^^^cJ^ ^ A faJLbr * &u~v&» ^^i' ^ S ^fei/. ^^ //fe &+Ml *4t*refct*' J Ifa ^f)

t-4sn-~-r£>

i

-

/ * IT

" >Z?77

^-z^

"/ ' TV "

,£^77'

7 -^ jCr-r-rr-^,

XT ^7°^

^ /*

b /'"Tyf^

*-y&s£>

ATO ^zn^o^f^

iji iic^ 0T»-)f

-n-or& ^ayyea^ -rw?

^/

V

' I/ '

JU-

t

"

-^y fr**

•ff

<*?

' n^L,

/

•

—w-yr

/

9pf ^°^ -f^-t-p.

^wy-r>7 r~**>j

ffy/

9-*~*iO*

&™-ja **jrfr£

JG^-~-rtKr-rrr

fc^eV<^/w*JVA_v

->-w~»_~C»

Q I JL J ?

.

w-»—»^»

SOLICITORS' APPRENTICE DEBATING SOCIETY OF IRELAND

SESSION

3L938 - 39.

OFFICERS :-

AUDITOR

-

-

-

-

Mr. M. J. Egsn B.A.

- Mr. P. J. fiutley

-

1Ir • L • ^ • Bo^d

HON.

TEEAEUEE

'

1*. L. M. 'Lev: ling-

COMMITTEE

:-

'

... .-SBES-

-

-.

•

•

;'V^"

Miss L. Pagan B.A.

•''-

i,r

Miss A. Hyland B.A.

Mr. T. Reilly

Mr. A Forroat Huaaey B.A. LL.b.

(Ex AvidAtor - Ex Officio

SOLICITORS' APPRENTICES' DEBATING SOCIETY.

The closing Meeting of the 55th Session of the Society was held on the 5th May,1939 in the Solicitors' Buildings,Pour Courts, Dublin. Mr. A.Forrest Hussey,LL.B. presided. The Minutes of the previous Meeting were read and signed without alteration.

The Auditor read his report on the affairs of the Society

during the Session.

Mr.B.J.Lynch proposed and Mr. Nutley seconded

that "the Auditors report be adopted". The report,after some minor

criticism was declared carried.

The Balance Sheet was read by the

Hon f Treasurer,Mr.P.J.Nutley. Mr.Kelly proposed and Mr.Lynch seconded

"that the balance sheet be adopted". The Motion was carried without

opposition.

The Auditor then declared the awards of prizes for the

Session 1938-'39 to be as follows:-

ORATORY ;

Society Silver Medal and Certificate.

................... Mr.P.J.Nutley.

Legal Deoate

: Society's Silver Medal...................Mr.A.Porrest Hussfey.

Impromptu Debate;

Society's Silver Medal ..................Mr.A.Porrest Hussey. Special Certificate ..................Mr.M.J.O'Higgins.

Irish Debate;

Society's Silver Medal ..................Miss s. Doorly. and Certificate.

First Year Speeches.

Society'3 Silver Medal and Certificate

................. Mr. P. P. 0« Sullivan.

'

""

A List of those who had received and returned Ballot papers was read

The result of the election of Officers and Committee ,

by Hon.Corr.Sec.

for the Session 1939-40. was declared as follows.

"

................................... Mr. M.J.Egan,B. A.

Auditor

Hon. Record Sec. ................................... Mr.P.J.Nutley. Hon.Corr.Sec. ................................... Mr.L.D.Boyd. Hon. Treasurer ................................... Mr .D.M. Bowling. - Commit tee";- i Miss L. Pagan,B. A. JUi Miss A.Hyland,B.A. Mr.T.O'Reilly. . Mr.A.Porrest Hussey,B.A.,LL.B. (Ex Auditor Ex Officio). The new Auditor and Committee then entered into office. Mr.Egan, the in- coming Auditor congratulated the out -going Auditor and Committee on a very successful year of office. Mr.Hussey(Ex Auditor) welcomed the new Auditor and Committee and wished them complete success. Mr.Higgins proposed and Mr. Grotty seconded the following Motion "That it is the considered opinion of this Society that for / the benifit of Apprentices who sincerely desire to obtain a satisfact- ory knowledge of Law and Practice during their term of service, the legal Practitioners' Qualification (Ireland) Act 1939 should be repeal- j ed . An amendment to this motion was proposed by Miss Betty Kelly j which read "that; the standard of the preliminary Irish examination be raised and that the second Irish examination be eliminated, except for those who afterwards wished to practise within the Gaeltacth to whom a Special certificate be awarded". After a long discussion the i motion was carried by 12 votes to 2. in accordance with Rule 71 of the Rules and Seeding Orde/Sj of the Society the Meeting terminated at eleven o'cloj

/*«.

/ed tilth

-ft ,W

trf

n

H 4u

Mftfn 7

*j k* JO«**Y L/xfivd. A A -f^eS y^i •fa&tt *&r **&££• ***"t (fa

•* d

•!,+•*•

M

•

' *

a- ti/

•

"9-1

/uf&* i^Ltkfn A&*. Q ft* \vU4&? 0P.

(U*L ZuMJUtWL *i*rt- fetHJ ^> **#*£<.

/?/$$& thntuJ: V foi

'

*

,

,

,

if

Jy^totvrf ^/^4-

j /^/^W-^^TT/" -KAA-4 *•' * / A/7 '- ttysyUd, ^ifuM, ^ckfaMwtf J**J*£A&1 / * . , SI f\ A '^WA^ uktitl

(j ^w z '^oMf /iMeirtJiL'A. id. ff.

n

A

n.

ft

tkd- $os ^£~

iUnlfa *t /&

/] >iht ,

if- /jviw.u4>

fat ML

Zi«f/&-ircafy J^AjJi M#4

A

i I *i

f1

i

\n ^

J&

J& fa<%dr~£iq&te Oe&A

/ fl &Hs sfcU t£~ JjLi*u$M~ '• Ml /C

I

l&oi

,/ /• ,d ' At/lftA Wbo J&{

Uf A / ,/Wrij^z>t ^

/\i*l fa ' J.

Jfc

/ / ^ /

/>.

/£«" A*&4* .

J&M^ /^/ x*4>

W foctl Jjfrffrti, . I .. /L

.

j~ / / »

-

/

C/

//~

/*/

/ / $*/ s

U&> /h+rf

/tec&Ji

/ #

-' L/

/rifff

?

''Sju'd /&/,

f / /A^i^^ Mert^kl ^4 , '/•/

!>^r(

\

M Jl It-

T

f)

'

(

I

^

$*

*

ts^f/rv H-^H

/o-t

>nf

*{••

Ml

/W&Mf M)&<4

4»l

fa

1+4.

$*%>

A^D

evL

*>/

^r

. C-

!>•.

/3. -* fl^, £• M /•/«

, u4 v .,/) (7

*/

,

]{• P. W

J.&

:^v /» AjU tfc PUMk ' D - r ^*^

A£

AM

" ^ W"

^*

. dr&ne^L sU^

fou4

flb

/$% /w

atiifi

/ /

fj fc

fit

/VWurt -^te

Y^/ 0c0

*>&>

A

)& ffc-

Il0u^n(fa* LY kuLiu

^^ fi^r jy^afael Jbf itr flttb^U y^ Mdti^

L-

ftl 4% iftlffL /£» '

4A

/f ^

Te-

#/Ci£b- 9v\_£wi/(M-r-) .

Q.

^(

D-

n M^^^u^^^ jQatAt&.frz (A^A^vicA^ *- /<-

C (KH^ii""-(£&/*<&

//ri4*yt KP-O ^ fc~ fce

f

• / /

,/

/—— -' ^ S-/«r. TUo ^tffoft f- ttn?r> Y'.^-^-MY- ./fe^i? .^^/e faese

*+(

Ajt*jA. (\ fas M ^ JjL

fr —-

jr zat&Ji

^*

it /UC- /ho ChJi'l^c£»*. x

*-, /WtY ^M^JlfcJr

/ ^ P /-^^^ >5ff- \4Jt^*fy*tjL

4

>

4*

/C&+*

*J-

** .

M /^W A ^ j y X* ^i*xxd

JL

X^

r\

/

A

o ,

,

,

,

\\

A dctut^lLvJc /"• ••

tudttL

dtvodJe.

•hvMLe

. ^.

.

I

fftu~

Jtr

/v

^v^-Ur

J] jjL yksujiL I

Q

1 U&r.

/

.#*-

\

x3

l^i cLetfi***.* J3~* &* ^Jtf-7

tL Oiv~l$

u^rv-

L

^?

£E /\*fU4v^f Jl $,

*

e\

.to*

-

/L CLdtfK, ,x ^JJ^ ti /hw^v A 4^" /U^^fU^, jf. /

/ ^£j*. ^i^st^^ frcdJ^s

A^-^i-^J tfi£es\

-faefiiitJty

\tCJM« *0«^> lu/a /p*,

/WHJL&vij ji £fa

Aj**J(A.JL

.(L+*l

/3

«/?

ftSLsrfLS**-*

T' JL&t^i*£

~

fi^rfuu-ek I*/ fat* yltUfo y^fcc&*^ a* J W ts

or*

rn<)-"**v

ffnjt

<7At*K

•

+-

^"^

7 ^-y-/ '/UwU /**

^U-/ M*4

fff>cfi&^

/iMJitt^*-A

Inj u)a*>

'

'

.

/

, ft

//

/*

y

T\

* /"

/A.

y

f?

faM*

,

1 iMiM J&JL

ft?** #1)Ma.

.

OwA

/-/Wife?.

Cfonc*

> AOX^ ^=> /itc£u>j~J * fu/fcMe^ h fc L

* J) fit /lrou*L Jfc t^' lfr*i] /£. a

Jt- tfuko a*"l Mhu&r Prtbt i/J

J^ (^Ji- d Jkbu£k

/S> /Z^b -^/^noL

£' dfe ^^AflK Jfc' SVLLirJ /k

/I * /&<&£

( a^

'pi'1 kfaftlii y><** ^f J?tT-vs/dt*y ^1/^co & /u*J if X' JK$jfy /fa s)tn*(L J) fa l/trlv&M. U^i H cenM^^JUif (s It it Cfafa*. JbZ 0t«faJ[. Jfc CiuMtfV Jb <*> ^r/iA«x^)^t 0 . ~.t Jfc £M^£tf 8>^> ^T"^extMV3 a. iA«x /ut* a

*Z ~Zi

J^flv^ /^ h-UL

ff

r

/

I

J

'

U

n

M ^uW f >-^A

L $Q~La* fa*J* Wu*tt*sJots sf n &

fl&OA& O^sr^^JL^

(w Vu>-i>^ J ,y£-ffu-tk H^ ^i^a^i^J rfv s*°J~^Lly^ &4' J^K^h ID y^ A-ttA ' " " ' ~ • •' "

/jfaZ fat, &£

45^ ^S~2cT ^tn^T. fa •

JL

.

/

0 \

' i

•

(X

C_T ; ™

ila

X*

"7 Z*

tw

tftf

'.,*

^te' ^£>O

.

t,

•rv&tn

<7

.

j^ fa /^SieU'" Y-"

a/ ^

-/—•

/*o^

&L

A

tit

f^l

le $T

/Jr-~- &tllejdsev^ J^nf /

(7

*f

OVA

fl

/

/>

. _

, ^U 0k

/1^ /t^pJfc ^ *fa r/fj*

CisUsaA^eti. /U^jL .

J/HA iA

• 4;

/ ^

- LJV

V

~ t A~ 4W<**- $<^ M . H. y o u " V V ~ I— I

•% '1^*"^ fa o

/ -^ »yv ^ _j*ur*dv

y™pr>w •&'-<&> (

W^/'^ ^•v^r-p.

,.

^**

J

r

*

rft

^y r*

X "

fr

f Jw

f-b

tL

. $L

TC

u^o^j

U_v=*ja«o(>A^o . &

UL.

•CUAxo-Ji-O^

Cuv-O^

N-C-O^*-

0

i

-\

Q

~%4rV

K>rM'x£x-^^t.

'

l

AD ^J/

^D i~T

•

A

^xJ^VU^

/Yv>OLc»^cj

tb

TVVy\ .

e-K^xv^ .

<5T5

IkaxJ^la

_

AX*.

IcT

OXi

ft

^rvRj&A-

V\j ovxLoA

.

/•

. ™

^\

\A) <*-X/a-^- .

cy\A

cP

0

l/lt-X^l

s\\Jlsr>JlS\f> —--^- 0 ,. ,^-

^T. -

--v_C^3^

V

vi , O ^

vQj^jA-^r-*-^^

>ti_>

/Ks»--wA>^-a-

La

^-Jkoo^^vi.

^<^< ^/ ^

.<9LJ?/ / ^ fe2y^l6iSC&£. j

d

I \}

•

'

fl

ran PN

ne? vcren4Kxr>O

^

^ ) u- eJk^ ^ ->>\je->i—^*-VD

^yn£^i^

XUxr^^UxUxlA^

^x

^

£&&&*^t

s&T*4

^X

/Iv

=5^?

P~ t tA&h-CoU sh*~jA

1

Ow O

cxA/M

S-,

crv^

^ tL

Uo

^Jt^

.

\xJG^-Uv^

2S

*„ -

Trvv /-

^

\\^J^2^A

crl"

^Q,«lXlAJLX.c«-AX^

L*>VVtQivX>VvJ3(^V---/9

(jK

1—

f~t

'

rvt

L 0

1 —

JLj>~~JSkjL*^*-*

\A*

\pa^-...ci

ut.

x^-t

)——xAXJ"V\J

/^^^T^

'

J

.

• on

vT. £?

C«o-*^**^ C/b&J

L*~t

l^j

^UYV^<~-

4*A.<^.J

£>' GL^V*-^

(OV\ •

tr

__

-m.. O'Q^U^ x UJtU^, . $^. ^t>o^ v*&^~*i l*-~'

-4*-^^ TVK.1 A_Ji_ , -I'l IT- inn- I ?f

bj^i&K. ^ N l^-

-rn^j, n

^&5j> ^-** ~ jSLe^ J x. sy***~v&«, f^(^*j» .

^\^^^}

"TP

r\A-\

(r^vv^rTra^

—I \l

G— i

^J

x^-t^y\

^-^try-«oxY

•~^>Y^^^rff~{

"Yl

-^^yv^-vxc

/° ^

yy^H,.

--V--X3 "v^r^-/fV

LI

V^T ,7?

^ j , -v ^iJj

(<*rr^

^r^^^O-^t^

/y-^P v

t*-*r . \<\

>,

/LA-L/jyi—

V->C'U<-'\X'-O

Q^CCA-^ .

48.

_

'^n^^U^f^/ df l*v xlc/v^tt.

(fa $

^

T

;oj^

/T/n^-w^Jj-e/i-o

tfc /rvsv-txxuL.

k^-cszju_&i*d

OK

'M'

ov (A

?

cr^L^*^ rK ">^>M

'^eArv.OxUAA^

IfV/V

tt ~

|^XA^

Pcr'

j* c -

iti

•i

•••'£-

*'.'4»

£L——a*-

1L

L^

i2

^2e^—(

J6-c

O»--cJ-«xr

-v-^

.

Cl^Jr

JL»*Jt

i

v

'3

£f*<\.

"To JX^2^ ^ ^tY^l^f^

*yr\ «S| W-^y-e^l^v^^Vrcv

*T>^v^i~*4s ,.. .^] •*, -,1*,^.^

ft>

' ^s~YT>~~r~3/3Df

V

C_

_?"| myo+o *-**

90

°**

~O

~I> or-*y~rr^tsru4/

+4

r

a

o^2/j^ ^ftTs

t:ryy ^ //^y

~^ 2f&^~t**\s'

/^y&>

^j^

71

/^^vwr *rano

i

cU»-/>

cf JLi<3

t/^

Ciy

)b*a/z

£

>c-. e

Mtfcr

/ it, vn

«£<»*xn/ £/ ClA^^^^CJ^ &d

CK-

p

I—

I -

^W

k^IxvA*-^

i

0

0

C\XxV>^ftJV-M

VlLe^vJlLA^Oc.

mTY^

KJ2o^s_^ CTW

5 ttL K^vCA/t

cvt^W. rvC.c^

'U/vL'K.

Jyv_AJ>* Jwi,